I just learned something new today.  After writing the post on long tail keywords, I tried to do more reading on keywords in general.  What I discovered was quite surprising, though.  I have always been a Google fan.  Despite the fact that they are way too harsh on paid posts (at least in my opinion) I think that they still deliver pretty good products.  So I thought that the Google Keyword Tool would be really good and useful.

According to Smackdown, though, it is not really that useful.  How so?  Here is an excerpt from the post:

Recently there was a bit of a hubbub surrounding Google’s Keyword Tool External (the keyword suggestion portion of AdWords that was made public a couple of years back). It started when a few people, like Barry Schwartz from SERoundtable, noticed that the tool was showing specific numbers for search terms instead of just green bars. Even though at first the numbers only appeared intermittently for people, the official Inside AdWords blog reported the change as a permanent one later that night.

The problem is, however, that those numbers are meant for people doing research into PPC traffic. The numbers shown have very little to do with what people actually search on using Google.com. I learned this the hard way about a year and a half ago, when I decided to try and use AdWords (the internal tool, the one that would actually show me estimated clicks based on position) to pick keywords that I might want to try and optimize for. I identified 3 phrases that I figured would be fairly easy to rank for (which they turned out to be). According to Google, being in the top 3 ad spots (which is as narrow as Google will estimate) I would get an estimated 141 to 180 clicks per day from all three phrases combined. Since natural serps get a slightly better CTR than ads usually do, I figured I would be golden if I could SEO my site to the top for those phrases. Not a ton of traffic, but with the conversion ratios I had on that site for targeted traffic, it would be more than worth it to spend the effort required to get those three phrases to the top.

What does this mean for us?  Perhaps we shouldn’t rely too much on this tool then.  Maybe Word Tracker is better?  Share your thoughts on this?

8 Comments to "Google Keyword Tool May Not Be Really Useful"

  • IT Governance Blog said:

    What I noticed is that the counts it shows are way higher than the counts the other tools show. By a factor of 10 in many cases. Does this mean the other tools were not accurate?

  • Hayabusa Parts said:

    I use the SEOBook keyword tool. It gives a little more info than just google. I’m not sure if it is any better or worse than the adwords tool. But I do use this information for finding long tail keywords.

    DT

  • Bill Jackson said:

    What is the HIPAA Privacy Rule and how does it relate to Senior Health Care?
    Chances are that you have heard of HIPAA and know that it is related to health care information. Ever wonder what that privacy policy form at the doctor’s office was for? Wonder no more because here you will find out what you need to know about HIPAA and how it affects seniors.

    HIPAA is the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act. It was passed by Congress in 1996 to protect the rights of Americans to have health insurance despite their job status and to have their health information remain private. It consists of two parts, Title I and Title II. The HIPPA Privacy Rule is part of Title II. So what are the provisions of this rule and how does it affect my elderly loved one’s care?

    The HIPPA Privacy Rule regulates how PHI (Protected Health Information) can be used or disclosed. PHI is defined as information that can be tied to an individual regarding their health status, health care provisions, and payment for health services. This includes any part of a patient’s health records or payment history. It does allow health care providers to release PHI when necessary to allow for treatment or payment but it requires that only the minimum amount of information be released to complete the needed transaction. Patients have to be notified when their information is disclosed and they must receive a disclosure of their rights under HIPAA-that is that form that you are given at the doctor’s office. Overall, HIPAA makes sure that your PHI is kept private, released only when absolutely necessary and that you are kept informed of its status/release.

    HIPAA is applied to certain covered entities which include hospitals and medical doctors. Senior Health Care is affected because it helps the patient remain informed of all things related to their health information. Covered entities do include senior health care providers like home health care providers, assisted living facilities, and nursing homes. If the facility is following HIPAA guidelines, your loved one’s information will always be kept confidential and they will be kept informed at all times.

    Look for a senior care provider that follows the HIPAA guidelines so that you can feel your PHI is safe at all times. Home Health Senior Care can provide you access to a network of senior health care professionals who are qualified to meet all of your health care needs. Contact us today to find out how!

    http://www.homehealthseniorcare.com

  • Dan Blackburn said:

    I think the number estimates have to be better than the old green bars. At least you can see a difference between all the maxed out keywords now. As a free tool, the adwords tool is not bad. I think giving estimate numbers over graphical display is an improvement.

  • Smart SEO Blog » Blog Archive » Google Insights: New SEO Tool said:

    [...] up with something new and useful for countless users all around the world. We have talked about the Google Keyword Tool and Google Alerts in previous posts. This time, they launched a new tool called Google [...]

  • Civil Site Design said:

    Interesting take. There is a lot of STUFF and some of it not worth the time.

  • SEO Blogging » » How To Find The Perfect Domain Name said:

    [...] course, you cannot merely guess what keywords are best to use. There are many tools online which can help you find keywords that are used a lot. Wordtracker is one. Webconfs also has a [...]

  • SEO Blogging » » Which Keywords – Long OR Short? said:

    [...] the previous post, I had a short introduction on short tail and long tail keywords. I differentiated the two kinds. Now the big question is this: which kind is better to use for your [...]

Please share your thoughts